Good Faith Violation: How to Follow the Rules of Cash Trading

Table of Contents

good faith violation

In recent years, the number of people engaging in cash trading has increased as more people are looking to profit from this exciting trading strategy. However, there are strict rules that govern cash trading to ensure that everyone involved in the system is adequately protected. One of these rules is in place to prevent traders from committing a good faith violation which is a serious matter and can result in severe penalties and fines.

In this article, we will cover what a good faith violation is, why the rule exists and what penalties you face if you violate the rules. We’ll also discuss other rules that apply to cash trading, as well as its benefits and risks so that you can make an educated decision about whether cash trading is the right trading strategy for you.


What is Cash Trading?

Cash trading is when you buy shares using only the money you have available in your account. This type of trading is in contrast to margin trading where you can buy shares using money borrowed from your broker. Many traders prefer cash trading to margin trading because there are no additional risks involved due to the use of borrowed money.

What is a Good Faith Violation?

A good faith violation is when you place an order for cash trading but your account doesn’t have enough funds to cover the full cost of purchasing all of those shares. Traders have two days within which to pay for shares and if you sell them within those two days without ever having the full amount, it is a breach of the rules. Good faith violations usually involve traders ordering shares they can’t afford and then selling them at a higher price before the original purchase has been paid for.

For example, you order 100 shares at a price of £500 when you only have money in your account to cover 80% of this purchase. If the stock’s price then rises to £600 and you sell them before you have paid the full initial price, it would be considered a good faith violation. This is because you didn’t have enough funds available in your cash trading account to buy them in full and there was no legitimate reason for placing an order that exceeded the amount of money currently available in your account.

The reason there are rules in place that govern available account funds is to ensure adequate protection for traders who use the system. If this rule wasn’t enforced then traders would be able to put through trades they were either unwilling or unable to pay. The rules are also there to prevent fraud, as it requires brokers to carefully monitor their clients’ available account funds before allowing them to place any orders for cash trading.

What are the Penalties for a Good Faith Violation?

The penalty you face if your order is not fully covered will depend on whether or not it was intentional or unintentional. Intentional violations are much more serious because they are considered fraud while unintentional violations aren’t as severe but can still lead to negative consequences such as having your trading privileges revoked temporarily or being charged fines by your brokerage firm. Potential penalties also depend on how much of a shortfall occurred when you placed your order.

cash trading price charts


What are Other Cash Trading Violations to Be Aware Of?

As well as good faith violations, there are also various other rules that govern cash trading, all of which can have potentially serious consequences if you are found to have breached those rules. Two of the most important rule breaches to be aware of are cash liquidation violations and freeriding violations.

Cash Liquidation Violations

Cash liquidation violations occur when you place an order for cash trading but your account doesn’t have enough available funds to cover the full cost of that purchase so you sell other shares to get the funds before the initial purchase’s settlement date.

For example, you have £0 in your account but you buy £500 of shares in Apple on Monday. The settlement date by which you must pay for those shares is Wednesday and so on Tuesday, you sell your shares in Microsoft for £500 to pay for the Apple ones.

This rule exists because some traders will cancel their order if they don’t have the funds available to cover it, so by selling shares first you are essentially falsely increasing your account’s equity. This rule is enforced because brokers must be able to monitor how much money each of their clients has access to before allowing them any orders for trading on that account.

Penalties for committing a cash liquid violation may include temporary suspension of your account and fines charged by your brokerage firm.

Freeriding Violations

Freeriding occurs when someone sells shares they already own but haven’t yet paid for in full and then uses the proceeds from selling these shares to pay for their initial transaction costs instead of paying them out-of-pocket themselves first before placing an order. Freeriding violates both good faith rules and other important regulations governing the responsibilities of brokers and traders.

Penalties for freeriding violations range from the possibility of temporary suspension to fines, depending on how severe your violation is deemed by brokerage firms.

How Can You Do Cash Trading Legally?

While there are potential penalties for good faith violations and other cash trading rules, many traders continue to use this method of buying and selling because it allows them the opportunity to get involved in trades they wouldn’t otherwise be able to make. Another important benefit is that with less money tied up per trade you can potentially accrue more capital through compound interest faster, which means your returns could increase significantly over time once you have built up enough funds available in your account.

Brokers must also take precautionary steps before allowing their clients to engage in any form of cash trading so as not to put themselves at risk of breaching the different regulations governing these types of transactions. It’s also vital that traders understand what is required from them when engaging in cash trading which is why it’s important to have knowledge of the different rules outlined in this article.

What are the Potential Benefits of Cash Trading?

One benefit of engaging in cash trading is being able to quickly increase your portfolio funds without going through any complicated procedures. Instead, clients simply need to deposit their money into an account set up by their brokerage firm then use discretion when placing orders on stocks they want to purchase or sell while monitoring market conditions closely throughout this process so brokers don’t break any rules themselves. This type of transaction also enables investors from all over the world to invest with ease since it takes just a few minutes to execute transactions after depositing the funds, unlike other types where some additional paperwork may be required.

Lastly, many investors find that they have a high success rate in terms of profits earned through cash trading instead of other types where more time and effort may be needed to conduct trades. While there are risks involved with cash trading, many traders see it as an effective way to make money without engaging in too much transaction activity which can affect their portfolio negatively over time.

cash trading


What are the Potential Risks of Cash Trading?

As explained above, the main risk of cash trading is that if you violate good faith rules or other regulations governing cash trades, you could be temporarily suspended from your brokerage firm as well as face fines. These penalties vary depending on how serious your violation was deemed by brokers so it’s important for all parties involved in this type of transaction to remain vigilant throughout the process so they don’t breach any rules.

Another potential risk is not being able to predict market movements accurately since with lower funds available per trade you’ll have slimmer margins for error before experiencing losses. For these reasons, many investors see it as a better practice to engage in cash trading only when necessary and then re-investing that money into their portfolio once they have built up enough funds available to make one or two larger trades.

How Can You Succeed in Cash Trading?

The best way to succeed in cash trading is by making sure you have the time, knowledge and money available necessary for this type of transaction. First off, if you are under pressure or don’t have enough time to conduct trades during normal business hours then it’s important not to use discretion with your brokerage firm so as not to risk violating any rules.

Secondly, since there are many potential penalties involved with good faith violations, it’s vital that traders know what they need to do before placing an order so brokers can monitor these transactions effectively without breaking any regulations themselves.

Finally, even though some investors may be tempted into using fewer funds per trade because of compound interest gains over time, remember that it’s always better to make more money through larger trades than lose it all due to smaller transactions.

How To Get Started With Cash Trading

If you are a beginner and want to get started with cash trading, the first step is to contact your brokerage firm so they can explain all of their rules for these types of transactions. Once you have outlined the methodologies used by both parties during this process, it’s important that brokers ensure traders comply with any regulations before allowing them to execute orders through discretion.

After completing this initial task, many investors choose to engage in one or two larger trades than several smaller ones because if there is an issue at hand then it will affect fewer funds available per trade. While there are other risks involved when engaging in cash trading such as not being able to accurately predict market movements due to lower margins for error while using less capital per order traded, it’s important to remember that the benefits of cash trading can outweigh these risks if you have a strategy in place and enough time available.

margin trading


Margin Trading Pros and Cons

The alternative to cash trading is margin trading where you use your assets as collateral to borrow funds from your brokerage firm for short-term investment purposes. While margin trading is attractive because of the potential for larger returns, it’s important that traders only engage in such transactions after they have outlined an effective strategy and can meet any additional requirements needed by their broker if there are issues with cash or credit balances at hand.

The main pros of margin trading include:

  • Having more money to invest in the market
  • Potentially earning higher returns on short-term investments due to use of borrowed capital

The main cons of margin trading include:

  • Being under constant pressure from brokers if there are issues with cash or credit balances at hand, which may lead to rules violations and temporary suspensions.  
  • Additional factors that can affect your final investment return such as dividends paid out by companies you have invested in. While this is something you should be aware of when engaging in any type of transactions involving stocks, it’s especially important for traders who engage in margin trading because these types of payouts will lower their overall rate of return depending on how high they had set their initial borrowing costs during negotiations with their broker.

Final Thoughts

To avoid breaking the rules when cash trading and committing a good faith violation, it is crucial that you always have enough money in your account to cover stock purchases. While it may be tempting to attempt to gain the system between the purchase and settlement dates, especially when an attractive opportunity arises, the potential penalties can be severe. Make sure you know all of the applicable regulations governing any type of trading or investing you engage in and this will enable you to trade without any hitches.


If you enjoyed this content you might also like the following;
Review of Seeking Alpha 2023
Motley Fool reviews 2023

Warrior Trading reviews

Review of Gorilla Trades

Review of Trade Ideas

Leave a Comment